Seam pipes for process industry - fracture analysis by using ring-shaped specimens

Main Article Content

Walid Musraty
Bojan Medjo
Nenad Gubeljak
Primož Štefane
Zoran Radosavljević
Zijah Burzić
Marko Rakin


Pipelines are commonly used in process industry for transport of fluids, as well as granular solids, due to their numerous advantages in comparison to other transportation means. Pipe integrity is essential for a reliable work of the entire plant, as well as for safety assurance. Also, serious ecological consequences may follow the pipeline failure in some cases, i.e. due to the leak of toxic, flammable or otherwise dangerous fluids in a chemical or some other plant. Therefore, it is very important to examine the fracture behaviour of pipelines, which is done here by testing the recently proposed ring-shaped specimens exposed to bending. The specimens were fabricated from a seam pipe for pressure applications (allowed for usage on temperatures up to 300 °C). Initial defects, very narrow notches, were machined either in the base metal and weld metal (seam) or in the base metal only. Regardless of the defect position, ductile fracture mechanism is observed in all specimens. The results show that the ring-shaped specimen can be successfully used for fracture characterisation of pipeline material, especially for thin-walled pipes which are not suitable for production of standard fracture mechanics specimens due to the insufficient wall thickness.

Article Details

Engineering of Materials - Metal materials


Dutta BK, Saini S, Arora N. Application of a modified damage potential to predict ductile crack initiation in welded pipes. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2005; 82: 833–839.

Gubeljak N, Vojvodić Tuma J, Šuštaršić B, Predan J, Oblak M. Assessment of the load-bearing capacity of a primary pipeline. Eng Fract Mech. 2007; 74: 995–1005.

Marenić E, Tonković Z, Skozrit I. On the calculation of stress intensity factors and J-integrals using the submodeling technique. J Pres Ves Technol. 2010; 132: 041203.1–12.

Zhang B, Ye C, Liang B, Zhang Z, Zhi Y. Ductile failure analysis and crack behavior of X65 buried pipes using extended finite element method. Eng Fail Anal. 2014; 45: 26–40.

Xu J, Zhang ZL, Østby E, Nyhus B, Sun DB. Constraint effect on the ductile crack growth resistance of circumferentially cracked pipes. Eng Fract Mech. 2010; 77: 671–684.

Kim YJ, Shim DJ, Huh NS, Kim YJ. Plastic limit pressures for cracked pipes using finite element limit analyses. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2002; 79: 321–330.

Dimić I, Arsić M, Medjo B, Stefanović A, Grabulov V, Rakin M. Effect of welded joint imperfection on the integrity of pipe elbows subjected to internal pressure. Tech Gaz. 2013; 20: 285–291.

Chiodo M, Ruggieri C. Failure assessments of corroded pipelines with axial defects using stress-based criteria: numerical studies and verification analyses. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2009; 86: 164–176.

Oh CK, Kim YJ, Baek JH, Kim YP, Kim WS. Ductile failure analysis of API X65 pipes with notch-type defects using a local fracture criterion. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2007; 84: 512–525.

Medjo B, Rakin M, Arsić M, Šarkoćević Ž, Zrilić M, Putić S. Determination of the load carrying capacity of damaged pipes using local approach to fracture. Mater Trans - JIM (Japan Institute of Metals and Materials). 2012; 53: 185–190.

Kozak D, Ivandić Z, Konjatić P. Determination of the critical pressure for a hot-water pipe with a corrosion defect. Mater Technol. 2010; 44: 385–390.

Mitrović N, Petrović A, Milošević M, Momčilović N, Mišković Ž, Maneski T, Popović P. Experimental and numerical study of globe valve housing. Hem Ind. 2017; 71:251–257.

Sedmak A, Algool M, Kirin S, Rakičević B, Bakić R. Industrial safety of pressure vessels - Structural integrity point of view. Hem Ind. 2016; 70: 685–694.

Kurth R, Kalyanam S, Kurth E, Wilkowski G, Brust F, Hattery G. Probability of brittle fracture in gas pipelines. In: Proceedings of ASME International Pipeline Conference, Volume 3, Calgary, Canada, 2014, pp. V003T12A030; 12 pages.

Martić I, Sedmak A, Tomić R, Hot I. Remaining life determination for pressure vessel in a refinery. Struct Integr Life. 2016; 16: 49–52.

Glišić D, Fadel A, Radović N, Drobnjak Dj, Zrilić M. Deformation behaviour of two continuously cooled vanadium microalloyed steels at liquid nitrogen temperature. Hem Ind. 2013; 67: 981–988.

Poberezhnyi L, Maruschak P, Prentkovskis O, Danyliuk I, Pyrig T, Brezinová J. Fatigue and failure of steel of offshore gas pipeline after the laying operation. Arch Civ Mech Eng. 2016; 16: 524–536.

Niu XC, Gong JM, Jiang Y, Bao JT. Creep damage prediction of the steam pipelines with high temperature and high pressure. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2009; 86: 593–598.

Panossian Z, de Almeida NL, de Sousa RMF, de Souza Pimenta G, Marques LBS. Corrosion of carbon steel pipes and tanks by concentrated sulfuric acid: A review. Corros Sci. 2012; 58: 1-11.

Okonkwo PC, Shakoor RA, Zagho MM, Mohamed AMА. Erosion behaviour of API X100 pipeline steel at various impact angles and particle speeds. Metals. 2016; 6: 232.

Dojčinović M. Roughness measurement as an alternative method in evaluation of cavitation resistance of steel. Hem Ind. 2013; 67: 323–330. (in Serbian)

Šarkoćević Ž, Rakin M, Arsić M, Sedmak A. Fabrication of high strength seam welded steel tubes and quality indicator testing. Struct Integr Life. 2008; 8: 81–98.

ASTM E1820: Standard test method for measurement of fracture toughness, American Society for Testing and Materials. 2015

Xu J, Zhang ZL, Østby E, Nyhus B, Sun DB. Effects of crack depth and specimen size on ductile crack growth of SENT and SENB specimens for fracture mechanics evaluation of pipeline steels. Int J Pres Ves Pip. 2009; 86: 787–797.

BS 8571: Method of test for determination of fracture toughness in metallic materials using single edge notched tension (SENT) specimens, British Standards Institution. 2014

Mahajan G, Saxena S, Mohanty A. Numerical characterization of compact pipe specimen for stretch zone width assessment. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct. 2016; 39: 859–865.

Koo JM, Park S, Seok CS. Evaluation of fracture toughness of nuclear piping using real pipe and tensile compact pipe specimens. Nucl Eng Design. 2013; 259: 198–204.

Likeb A, Gubeljak N, Matvienko Y. Finite element estimation of the plastic ηpl factors for pipe-ring notched bend specimen using the load separation method. Fatigue Fract Eng Mater Struct. 2014; 37: 1319–1329.

Gubeljak N, Likeb A, Matvienko Y. Fracture toughness measurement by using pipe-ring specimens. Proc Mater Sci. 2014; 3: 1934–1940.

Medjo B, Rakin M, Gubeljak N, Matvienko Y, Arsić M, Šarkoćević Ž, Sedmak A. Failure resistance of drilling rig casing pipes with an axial crack. Eng Fail Anal. 2015; 58: 429–440.

Musraty W, Medjo B, Gubeljak N, Likeb A, Cvijović-Alagić I, Sedmak A, Rakin M. Ductile fracture of pipe-ring notched bend specimens - micromechanical analysis. Eng Fract Mech. 2017; 175: 247–261.

Likeb A. Suitability of pipe-ring specimen for determination of fracture toughness. PhD Thesis, University of Maribor, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering, Slovenia, 2014 (in Slovenian)

Gajdos L, Sperl M. Evaluating the integrity of pressure pipelines by fracture mechanics. In: Belov A, ed. Applied Fracture Mechanics. Rijeka: InTech; 2012: 283–310.

Bergant M, Yawny A, Perez Ipiña J. Numerical study of the applicability of the g-factor method to J-resistance curve determination of steam generator tubes using non-standard specimens. Eng Fract Mech. 2015; 146: 109–120.

Damjanović D, Kozak D, Matvienko Y, Gubeljak N. Correlation of Pipe Ring Notched Bend (PRNB) specimen and Single Edge Notch Bend (SENB) specimen in determination of fracture toughness of pipe material. Fatigue Fract Engng Mater Struct. 2017; 40: 1251–1259.

Arcelor Mittal. Inspection certificate no. 33131/1, Arcelor Mittal Iasi, Romania, June 6, 2015.

GOM Precise Industrial 3D Metrology. Accessed August 28, 2017.

Gubeljak N. Application of stereometric measurement on structural integrity. Struct Integr Life. 2006; 6: 65–74.

Schmidt T, Tyson J, Galanulis K, Revilock D, Melis M. Full-field dynamic deformation and strain measurements using high-speed digital cameras. In: Proceedings of the International Society for Optical Engineering SPIE, Alexandria, VA, USA, 2005, pp. 174–185.

GKSS. Displacement gauge system for applications in fracture mechanics. Patent publication. Geesthacht: GKSS Research Center Publications. 1991

Gubeljak N, Chapetti M, Predan J, Landes J. CTOD - R curve construction from surface displacement measurements. Eng Fract Mech. 2011; 78: 2286–2297.

ESIS P2-92: Procedure for determining the fracture behaviour of materials. European Structural Integrity Society, 1992.